Amir's Notes

Amir’s Notes · November 20, 2026

The Secret to Good Mussar

In Parshat Vayeitzei, when Yaakov arrives at the well in Charan after his dream, he sees shepherds waiting around instead of tending their flocks. He eventually rebukes them: “The day is still long… give the sheep to drink and go pasture them.”

But before he says a word of criticism, the Torah highlights something surprising:

“Vayomer lahem Yaakov: Achai — mei’ayin atem?”
“My brothers, where are you from?” (Bereishit 29:4)

Yaakov begins by calling them brothers.
Then he makes small talk.
Then he asks about Lavan.
Only after that does he challenge their behavior.

Read the entire Dvar Torah here.